How I Make Decisions
Copy the decision system I run on my own business: filter what gets in, argue both sides before you commit, check the objective is still yours, and keep score on your own rulings.
By James Schramko · Updated August 2026
Decisions are the real product of your role. The team executes and the market responds. The calls you make are the only thing that was ever yours alone. Most founders run those calls on mood, memory and whoever they spoke to last. I run mine through a system, and the system is simple enough to copy.
Only Diamonds Get In
For years I filled journals at events. Pages of capture, pages of notes, everything recorded. Later I noticed I never went back to any of it. The notes had no return. The capture felt like work and produced nothing.
I flipped it. Now nothing gets into my system unless it survives compression. After a key moment I write one or two lines. If an idea cannot survive being cut to two lines, it was not a diamond, and I let it go past.
The current trend runs the other way: hardware that records everything, transcribes everything, stores everything. That is coal-catching. It feels productive. It gives you more capture and no better judgment. Information is now endless and free. The scarce thing is meaning. A system built on capture instead of judgment is broken at the base.
Run it yourself. Before anything enters your notes, your task list or your plans, cut it to two lines. Whatever survives that cut is worth keeping.
The Three-Question Filter
Every commitment already in the business gets tested against three questions. I built this filter years ago. It has outlived every tool I have run it in.
- If it does not support revenue, delivery, or proof, remove it.
- If two options exist, one is wrong. Pick.
- If I hesitate, it does not belong.
These are blunt on purpose. They are the fast pass for the standing clutter: the subscriptions, campaigns and commitments competing for the same time, money and attention. The big, hard-to-reverse calls never get the fast pass. They go through the full system below. Inside its lane, the third question does the most work. Repeated hesitation about whether something belongs is a reason to re-test it, never a reason to keep it.
There is a fourth question under the other three, and I ask it before any new piece of work starts. Does this work need to exist at all? Most projects fail that question before they fail in the market. The cheapest decision you will ever make is deleting something before it starts.
Argue Both Sides Before You Decide
For any decision that matters, I do not ask my AI what to do. I make it argue. Both sides, in full, before I form a position. I assign roles and make them fight it out: an accountant, a lawyer, a sceptic, a buyer, whatever chairs the decision needs. Marc Andreessen described a similar approach publicly in May 2026: steelman both sides, build a panel of expert personas, then make the judgment yourself. I had been running my version for years before that. It has saved me from costly commitments that sounded great in my own head.
Three rules make it work in practice. Each one exists because I learned it the hard way.
Discount the marginal findings. A reviewer never comes back empty, because finding nothing feels like failing the job. Coming back clean does not make you right, and a long list of small quibbles is no sign you are wrong. Weigh the material findings and discard the rest.
One round per decision. Argue it once, judge the findings, decide. If you re-run the challenge until it agrees with you, you are shopping for the answer you wanted. A second round needs new evidence.
Check the base rate. Ask what usually happens to people who make this exact move. Your inside view rarely matches the record. When your models disagree about that, the disagreement itself is a signal. I keep a separate playbook on exactly that: AI Outside View.
Is the Objective Still Yours
The most costly failure in decision-making is good reasoning aimed at a stale objective. You can argue a decision perfectly and still get it wrong. The goal it serves stopped being your goal a year ago, and nobody told the plan.
The last check before committing is one question. What objective does this decision serve, and do I still want that objective? Businesses outgrow their goals quietly. The founder chasing scale who really wants freedom. The operator defending a product line that belongs to an earlier identity. Ask the question in plain words. If the objective is stale, no amount of good reasoning downstream can save the decision.
Keep Score On Your Own Rulings
I log my strategy decisions with a status: active, resolved or superseded. Superseded is a healthy word. It means new evidence came in and the ruling got updated. That is the system working.
Count your own overturns. If nothing in your decision log ever gets revised, check whether new evidence can really change your mind. A validation process that never changes your mind is a yes-man with extra steps.
The Human Outside the Storm
Most of this system should run without anyone else, and you should run it that way. The exception is a decision where your own stake in the outcome makes it hard to judge. When you are inside that decision, you are also inside the weather that made it urgent. The cash pressure, the ego, the sunk years, the identity tied to the old plan. The models will argue whatever you point them at. You chose where to point them.
The calibrator has to stand outside your storm. Someone who has seen the pattern enough times to say: I know it feels unique to you, and here is what usually happens next. That role does not compress into a prompt. Its whole value is that it does not share your weather.
Quick Reference
- Compress everything to two lines before it gets in. What cannot survive compression was not a diamond.
- Run the fast-pass filter on standing commitments. Revenue, delivery or proof. Two options means one is wrong. Repeated hesitation means re-test it.
- Ask whether the work needs to exist before asking how to do it.
- Make your AI argue both sides in assigned roles before you form a position. One round. Discount the marginal findings. Check the base rate.
- Before committing, confirm the objective the decision serves is still your objective.
- Log rulings with a status and count your overturns. If nothing ever gets revised, check the process can really change your mind.
- Keep one calibrator outside your own weather for the decisions you are too close to.
That is the seat I hold for every founder inside Mentor: someone outside your weather who has seen the pattern enough times to say what usually happens next.